The Science Behind Why Magnets Don’t Stick To All Metals

Without a doubt, magnets are quite fascinating. From fridge doors to high-tech MRI machines, they’re everywhere. But despite how often we encounter them, many people still believe one common myth: magnets attract every type of metal. It’s easy to see where this comes from. After all, you’ve probably seen magnets stick to fridges, tools, or even bits of scrap metal. So surely they must attract all metals, right? Not quite.

This misunderstanding is actually a great example of how science can surprise us once we dig a little deeper. It’s also the sort of topic that often sparks curiosity in primary science tuition, where young learners first start questioning how things really work. To get to the truth, we’ll need to take a closer look at the science behind magnetism and find out which metals truly have a magnetic personality.

Can magnets attract everything made of metal?

Let’s start with one of the most surprising facts about metals: not all of them are magnetic. Magnets mainly attract what we call ferromagnetic metals, namely iron, cobalt, and nickel. There are also a few lesser-known examples, such as gadolinium, neodymium, and samarium. Alloys containing these metals, like certain types of steel, will also respond strongly to magnets.

But once you move away from ferromagnetic materials, things get more complicated. Metals like aluminium, magnesium, and platinum are paramagnetic, meaning they show a very weak attraction to magnets. The pull is so slight that you wouldn’t notice it in daily life. Then there are ferrimagnetic materials, such as magnetite, which behave similarly to ferromagnetic metals but with a twist in their atomic structure. And finally, there are diamagnetic metals, including copper, silver, and lead which aren’t attracted to magnets at all. In fact, they’re slightly repelled.

So, while all ferromagnetic metals are metals, not all metals are ferromagnetic. The idea that “metal equals magnetic” is therefore more myth than fact.

Why the misconception exists

One big reason people assume magnets attract all metals is because of what they see in everyday life. For example, a magnet might cling to a steel refrigerator door, leading to the belief that it would do the same with any metal. But what’s really happening here is that the fridge door contains iron, a ferromagnetic material.

Speaking of steel, you might be surprised to learn that not all types of stainless steel are magnetic. Some contain higher amounts of chromium or nickel, which disrupt the atomic arrangement that allows magnetism to form. So, two pieces of “steel” can behave completely differently when you bring a magnet close. This is the sort of detail that often fascinates students exploring materials and forces, especially when guided by a primary science tutor in Singapore who can demonstrate these effects hands-on.

Getting back on track, even metals that aren’t truly magnetic can behave in puzzling ways under certain conditions. Take aluminium, for instance. If you move a magnet quickly near an aluminium plate, the metal may appear to react to the magnetic field. This is because the moving magnet induces eddy currents in the aluminium, generating a temporary opposing magnetic field. But that’s not genuine magnetism, it’s a short-lived electromagnetic effect caused by motion.

Understanding how magnetism works

To understand why some metals stick to magnets while others don’t, we need to look at what magnetism actually is.

At its core, magnetism is the result of moving electric charges. Every electron behaves like a tiny magnet because it has a property called spin. You can think of this spin as a miniature magnetic field. When electrons spin in random directions, their magnetic effects cancel each other out. But if many of them spin in the same direction, their magnetic moments align and strengthen one another, creating a larger magnetic field.

Electrons also orbit the nucleus of the atom, adding another layer of magnetism. In most materials, these orbits and spins cancel each other out, so no overall magnetic field remains. But in certain metals like the ferromagnetic ones, the atomic structure allows these magnetic moments to align across entire regions called magnetic domains. When these domains point in the same direction, the material itself becomes magnetic.

The types of magnetism explained

Let’s take a closer look at the four main types of magnetism found in metals and how they differ.

1. Ferromagnetism

Ferromagnetic materials like iron, cobalt, and nickel have unpaired electrons and a crystal structure that encourages their magnetic moments to align. This alignment can persist even when the external magnetic field is removed, which is why magnets made from these materials stay magnetic.

Many alloys also fall into this category. For instance, stainless steel with high iron content, or specialised mixtures like alnico (a blend of aluminium, nickel, and cobalt). These materials are what most people think of when they picture something “magnetic”.

2. Paramagnetism

Paramagnetic metals, such as aluminium and platinum, also have unpaired electrons, but their atomic structures don’t allow magnetic domains to form. This means that while they’re slightly attracted to magnets, the effect disappears as soon as the external field is removed. The attraction is so weak that you’d never see it outside of a laboratory setting.

3. Ferrimagnetism

Ferrimagnetism is a little trickier. It occurs when materials have two opposing magnetic structures that don’t perfectly cancel each other out, leaving a small net magnetic field. Magnetite, a naturally magnetic mineral, is a good example. While ferrimagnetic materials share similarities with ferromagnets, many of them are ceramic rather than metallic, which can make them seem like an odd exception to the “metal and magnet” conversation.

4. Diamagnetism

Diamagnetic materials are the opposite of ferromagnetic ones. They have no unpaired electrons, so when a magnetic field is applied, the electrons adjust their motion slightly to oppose the field. As a result, diamagnetic materials are repelled by magnets, although the effect is weak. Silver, copper, and lead all fall under this category.

Conclusion

In short, magnets only attract certain metals. The strength of attraction depends on the metal’s internal structure and how its electrons are arranged. Ferromagnetic metals are the main types of metals that respond to a magnet’s pull, while paramagnetic and ferrimagnetic materials only do so to a slight degree. Diamagnetic metals, on the other hand, actively repel them altogether.

Understanding this not only clears up a common misconception but also reveals how elegant and precise nature’s rules can be. So, the next time someone claims that “magnets attract everything metal”, you’ll know exactly why that isn’t true, and you might even enjoy setting the record straight.

Want to make learning science more fun and engaging? At Heuristics Science, we provide science tuition classes that do exactly that, as well as spark curiosity and strengthen understanding through our proven TCR Answering Technique and hands-on learning. Enrol today and start building a strong foundation in science with confidence.